Friday, December 05, 2008

Needed: A Large Drop of Helicopter Money

During the past half year, the concerns of the Fed have shifted from worry about commodity-driven inflation (recall $147 oil in July) to its polar opposite--fear about the onset of deflation (coinciding with oil falling below $40 today). With short-term interest rates now lower than the targeted 1% rate, traditional monetary policy measures have become less potent and the U.S. economy is more susceptible to descending into a "liquidity trap." As mentioned by Ben Bernanke in a 2002 speech, one way out of such a predicament is a "helicopter drop"--effectively dropping money from helicopters to consumers and businesses below in order to thwart deflation, stimulate spending and prevent economic stagnation.

Consumer-Based Crisis

The financial crisis we are facing today first surfaced a year and a half ago as a consumer-based subprime mortgage problem that soon developed into an institutional credit crisis, morphed into a pervasive illiquidity dilemma, and earlier this week was, long after the fact, officially named an economic recession that began 12 months ago! As parallels with the Great Depression of the 1930s and Japan's stagnant economy of the 1990s grow more conspicuous, the gloomy predictions of NYU economist Nouriel Roubini loom larger and closer. We are now one year into a recession that, according to Roubini, will most likely extend at least another year. What began as a seemingly minor problem has expanded into a full-blown, global financial crisis that could very well extend into 2010, becoming the most severe economic downturn in the adult lifetime of anyone alive today--unless, of course, our policymakers take appropriate and sufficiently drastic measures to stabilize the financial system.

Bush, Bernanke and Paulson have tried to fix the problem with a whole series of measures--a moderately sized consumer stimulus package in early 2008, bailouts of financial institutions, successive rate cuts, capital infusions to strengthen bank balance sheets, an increased limit on bank deposit insurance, government backstops on portfolio asset losses, purchases of illiquid assets, etc. So far, nothing has worked as well as anyone would like, and our faltering economy and plunging real estate and stock markets continue week after week to drive each other lower, in a relentless asset deflation spiral that is dragging down even the endowments of elite institutions like Harvard. Come January 20, President-elect Obama (incidentally, a Harvard Law alumnus) and newly appointed Treasury secretary Geithner will replace Bush and Paulson, respectively, and we can only hope that the stimulus package in Obama's vision for the future of our economy will be large enough to usher in real change in a favorable direction.

As for the root cause of our economic problems, the consensus opinion among economists and laymen alike implicates overleverage, basically too much debt and too little savings, particularly among consumers. Everyone agrees that saving more would be prudent for any individual consumer facing an uncertain future, but when aggregate consumption falls our economy unfortunately enters a vicious circle, as reduced consumer demand (from saving more) leads to reduced delivery of goods and services and higher unemployment, which, in turn, reduces demand still further. To halt this vicious circle before it does further collateral damage to our fragile economy, we need to find a practicable way to provide debt relief at the consumer level--as soon as possible. This is where the helicopter money comes in.

Helicopter Money Initiative

As Bernanke pointed out in his speech, even when monetary policy by itself becomes ineffective, there are a number of alternative ways to combine monetary policy with fiscal stimulus to prevent deflation and encourage economic growth, despite being in a near-zero interest rate environment like the one we are experiencing today. These less traditional, more innovative measures are:

A. Broad-based tax cuts,
B. Increased purchases of goods and services by the government,
C. Purchase of private assets via the Treasury, and
D. Increased direct transfer of money from the government to the private sector.

President-elect Obama is already planning to provide tax cuts (measure A above) to at least 95% of Americans and some talk of reducing payroll taxes is also circulating. The large (maybe $1 trillion?) stimulus package (measure B) currently under discussion in Congress will hopefully be ready for signing by inauguration day. Purchase of private assets (measure C) is already underway in the commercial paper and mortgage-backed security markets, but practical limitations (i.e., how to price highly illiquid instruments) have prevented the proposed wide-scale purchase of toxic mortgage assets that was the main objective the initial TARP plan. Consumer stimulus packages (measure D), along the lines of the one implemented in the first half of 2008, work most directly and immediately to maintain GDP growth and, for this reason, deserve further serious consideration.

Because near-term inflation is no longer an issue, policymakers now have the luxury of taking the most aggressive actions possible to turn our economy around. With the financially stressed, heavily indebted American consumer so central to our problems, it makes sense to implement an enhanced version of measure D--this time in much larger size. Just as people suffering in the aftermath of a natural disaster need immediate and basic emergency assistance, prior to tax-related benefits and government spending to rebuild infrastructure, our severely damaged economy needs a very significant injection of helicopter money delivered directly to the overleveraged consumer.

To achieve the quickest and most direct money transfer to the consumer, here's what our government should do:
Beginning during the first half of 2009, write checks to every household filing a tax return, in the amount of, say, $10,000 per dependent (taxpayer, spouse, children, other household members), which is an order of magnitude larger than the consumer stimulus in early 2008.
Offhand, it might appear that this type of seemingly frivolous fiscal policy would be a desperate and highly wasteful use of taxpayer money that could spark a new, undesirable bubble. However, given the precarious state of our economy, such a radical measure stands a greater chance of doing more good than harm and has many benefits:

1. Immediate and Direct Impact: Helicopter money provides an immediate stimulus to consumers and businesses, directly benefiting Main Street (a refreshing change after all the prior rescue plans with trillions of dollars going to Wall Street financial institutions);

2. Reduced Consumer Leverage: Consumers will use some of the money to pay down mortgages, credit card debt, car loans, etc.;

3. Increased Consumption: Consumers will use some of the money to do what consumers do best, i.e., buy products and services, which will immediately boost sales of businesses large and small, preventing further job destruction;

4. Market Support: Some of the money will be invested in the stock and real estate markets, relieving downward pressure on asset prices and helping to create the market bottom that is so badly needed to build consumer and investor confidence and turn our economy around;

5. Global Economic Growth: Reduced consumer leverage, increased consumption and increased investment will all boost the U.S. economy, which in turn will help revive the global economy.

With the U.S. population at about 300 million, this new consumer stimulus package of $10,000 per person would total $3 trillion, which is about four times the $700 billion TARP package but less than half of the approximately $8 trillion in cumulative funds the government has already committed through all of the various measures announced. The net effect of this helicopter money plan would be to shift up to $3 trillion of debt from the consumer to the government. This would reduce leverage at the consumer level and boost aggregate demand to stave off a deflationary spiral.

As Professor Roubini points out in this interview, the basic structural problem we face is a global supply glut cannot immediately be reduced even though demand has fallen. Therefore, at least in the short run, the severity of the current crisis justifies "pulling out all stops" to create the demand necessary to meet existing supply. A large helicopter drop appears to be exactly what is needed to stabilize our economy and sidestep the negative impact that further deterioration in employment and the housing and stock markets will otherwise bring.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Stock Assault 2.0 Artificial Intelligence Stock Market Software, FREE DEMO, 100% Guaranteed, 60 day 100% money back guarantee! Support available! Try it out today!

10:14 PM, December 11, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

There is some evidence -- from Japan --- to suggest that if things are bad enough, people and institutions will simply plough any incentive payments back into savings or use it to pay down debt. In the case of Japan in the 1990s, the cash the government tried to pump into the system was simply used to buy Japanese Government Bonds or put into Postal Savings, effectively returning the money to the government while at the same time pushing yields to zero.

5:44 AM, December 12, 2008  
Blogger GD said...

Hey lloyd for some reason the economy made me think of you. Something tells me I'm having a lot more fun with coupled-bunch instabilities than you are with hedge funds whatever they are. Don't forget your application to AAAS - "We thought you'd like to learn about ribosomes"... GD

7:39 AM, December 12, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

How to turn $10 into $10,000 in 14 days with Paypal !!
$$ Make Money Business Opportunity $$


Dear Friend,
This is a new program as you will see. It can be used in the U.S. or the U.K. This is a fantastic opportunity, try it for yourself!! EVERYTHING IS DONE ONLINE!! With just £5 or $10 and a Paypal PREMIER or BUSINESS account, you could make $$Thousands$$ in 2 SIMPLE STEPS!!
READ THIS VERY CAREFULLY THEN READ IT AGAIN. THIS IS FAST; THIS IS NOT THE ONE YOU WILL BE WAITING TO WORK. GUARANTEED - you will have $10,000 in two weeks. Only $10, a Paypal PREMIER or BUSINESS account and 30 min are all that is needed to get this going. GIFTING MADE EASY, PLEASE READ ON TO FIND OUT HOW If you want to make a few thousand dollars real quick, then please take a moment to read and understand the MLM program I’m sharing with you. NO IT’S NOT what you think. YOU DON’T have to send $10 to five or six people to buy a report, receipt or get on their mailing list. Nor will you need to invest more money later to get things going. THIS IS THE FASTEST, EASIEST PROGRAM EVER, you will be able to complete it in LESS THAN 30 MINUTES and you will never forget the day you first viewed this online.
If you’re already running a home business, you can easily do this one along with it. If not, this is the FASTEST and EASIEST way to earn serious money online that you’ve ever seen so far in the history of the Internet! This program works no matter what country you are in, or what currency you use.
It doesn’t matter how old or how young you are. And you certainly won’t need any special knowledge or talent. You won’t need to run a website, or make phone calls, or make photocopies, or send out letters through the mail, or pay for advertising, etc. The only things you will need are:
• An email address
• A Premier or Business PayPal account with at least
$10 deposited in it
• 30 minutes of your time

ONLY 2 SIMPLE AND EASY STEPS!! If you are doing other programs, by all means stay with them. The more the merrier, BUT PLEASE READ ON!! First of all, there are only TWO POSITIONS, not four, five or six like many other programs. This program is more realistic and much, MUCH FASTER. Because it is so easy, the response rate for this program is VERY HIGH and VERY FAST, and you will receive your reward in FOURTEEN DAYS. That’s only TWO WEEKS - not one or two months- just in time for next months BILLS!! TRUE STORY --> Grace Kelly tells how she ran this gifting summation four times last year. The first time, she received $6,000 in cash in two weeks and then $14,000 in cash the next three times. When this program is continued, as it should be, EVERYONE PROFITS!! DON’T BE AFRAID to send gifts to strangers. It will come back to you ten folds. A person can give you up to $10,000 per year and you don’t have to report it to the IRS. THIS CAN AND WILL WORK FOR YOU! HERE ARE THE DETAILS:
Post this letter in 50 message boards, chat rooms, or newsgroup. You don’t need to post 200 like other programs or email 100 people just to get started. Even if you are already in a program like the send twenty dollars to six people, CONTINUE IT and stay with it, THOSE DO PAY OUT, but do yourself a favor, DO THIS ONE TODAY as well, RIGHT NOW!!! It is simple and takes a very small investment, only $10 and a Paypal PREMIER or BUSINESS account. IT WORKS AND IS DONE IN 2 SIMPLE AND EASY STEPS!! This program WILL PAY FASTER before the other programs you are working on even trickle in!!
Just give one person $10. THAT’S IT!! Follow the simple instructions and in two weeks, you should have $10,000 because most PEOPLE WILL RESPOND due to the LOW ONE TIME INVESTMENT, SPEED AND HIGH PROFIT POTENTIAL. PLUS, since it’s done all ONLINE, there is no time wasted mailing out letters and such!! We are not even figuring a 50% response! So let’s all keep it going and help each other in these tough times. We all owe money to bill collectors, and creditors. But, with this, if people take the time to help each other, the good fortune will follow. SO, Take the measly minutes this SIMPLE and REWARDING program offers and give the gift that gives back TODAY!!
Simply send a $10 gift to the person at POSITION #1, if your birthday is BETWEEN JAN 1 THRU JUNE 30, OR, if your birthday is BETWEEN JULY 1 THRU DEC 31, send the gift to the person at POSITION # 2. HERE’S WHAT YOU NEED TO DO. . .
Ok, if you’re not already a PayPal user, the very first thing you need to do is use the PayPal link below and SIGN UP. It takes just two minutes!
Here’s the URL:
Be sure to use this link so you can sign up for a free PREMIER or BUSINESS account. You’ll need to have a PREMIER or BUSINESS account (and not a PERSONAL account) otherwise you won’t be able to receive credit card payments from other people.
It is an undeniable law of the universe that we must first give in order to receive. So the first thing to do when you have your Premier/Business PayPal account is to IMMEDIATELY send a $10 payment from your PayPal account to the email address in the position (1 or 2 - depending on your birthday in the timeline), along with a note saying: “HERE IS A $10 GIFT FOR YOU.”
Be certain to add this note, as this is what KEEPS THIS PROGRAM LEGAL. Instructions on how to send a payment are under “SEND MONEY” at the Paypal Site. It’s so easy!!
When you send your $10 payment to the first address in the list, do it with a great big smile on your face because “as you sow, so shall you reap!”
After you have transferred a $10 payment to the email address, something very eerie happens. It gives you an indescribable, overwhelming sense of certainty, belief and conviction in the system. You’ve just proved to yourself that, because you have done it, there must be a great number of other people ready to do exactly the same. Thus you have now seen for yourself, first hand, that this business actually works! REMOVE the email address you are replacing (the one you sent $10 to), and REPLACE it with your own email address.
REMEMBER: Use the same EMAIL ADDRESS that is used with YOUR Paypal account!!
Paste your newly typed email address over the old one and then post to 50 Message Boards, Chat Rooms, or Newsgroups. DON’T MULL OVER IT, JUST 30 MIN OF YOUR TIME, THAT’S IT THERE IS NO MORE TO DO!! ACT FAST AND GET THE GIFT. HONESTLY AND INTEGRITY MAKE THIS PLAN WORK!! DO TO OTHERS AS YOU WOULD HAVE THEM DO TO YOU.
YOUR NAME COULD CYCLE FOR A LONG TIME!! THIS MAKES IT THE GIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING. This is excellent seed money to start or expand a business, buy you dream home, car, and pay off what ever bills you may have. Good luck and God Bless. Play fairly, Good fortune will follow. WHY THIS PROGRAM WORKS:
Straight to the point, the reason this program is SO SUCCESSFUL is because when you follow these instructions EXACTLY = GIVE A $10 GIFT and POST this in 50 different message boards, there are only TWO outcomes.
(1) A person’s birthday will fall on the same half as yours, therefore, YOU GET THE $10…
(2) a person’s birthday will fall on the other half of the timeline, therefore, YOU STAY IN YOUR POSITION and get posted in 50 other MESSAGE BOARDS, etc... BOTTOMLINE: Either you get the $10 or your name gets passed on for other people to give YOU $10 or pass YOUR name on to other people that will. It makes you think though, the more you POST YOUR OWN POSTS, the BETTER the results!!
• QUICK, SIMPLE AND CHEAP TO GET STARTED! So there it is. You now have the knowledge that will enable you to make over $10,000 within the next two weeks. The only thing that can hold you back now is a lack of faith or a lack of self-belief. However, any doubts you may currently have will disappear within a few days of putting this plan into practice. Trust me on this! You certainly won’t regret it.
SOME NOTES FROM PAYPAL WHICH YOU MAY FIND USEFUL PayPal lets you pay anyone with an email address and is the world’s Number 1 online payment service. PayPal is accepted on over 3 million eBay auctions as well as a countless number of online shops. You can also use PayPal to pay your friends - for example, it’s a convenient way to split the phone bill with your room-mate, send cash to your kids in college, or send cash to someone in another country. Better yet, you can also earn a referral bonus of up to $100 each time someone signs up for a PayPal account using your referral URL!
When you send money through PayPal, you can fund your payments with your credit card or checking account. You won’t have to worry about your privacy, because PayPal keeps your accounting information safe and secure. Making a purchase with PayPal is far more secure than mailing a check or giving your credit card number to a stranger. That’s why over 9 MILLION people from around the world use PayPal to move money. Signing up for a PayPal account is free, easy, and it takes only a couple of minutes.
Thank you and good luck in your ventures
P.S. Does this sound too good? Well maybe to some skeptics it is. But it actually works, and is worth the 30 minutes of your time now. So, just make a nice cup of tea and get started on it now. After all, you can’t lose, but you stand to gain more in the next few weeks than many people earn in a few months…

7:59 AM, December 15, 2008  
Blogger FCFI said...

All are welcome to seek alternative investments during this crisis of confidence with banks.

10:07 AM, December 16, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Lloyd. Wondering what you think of the data compiled in Geezeo Main Street Spending Index?

6:39 AM, December 22, 2008  
Blogger Covered Calls Advisor said...

Where have you disappeared to?
As soon as you made a believer of me and I put you in my Google Reader feed, you've stopped posting -- haven't received any words of wisdom from you in a month now.
Hello there!
Hello there!
Are you listening?

7:43 PM, January 02, 2009  
Anonymous Anonymous said...














1:38 AM, September 22, 2009  
Anonymous stock market for beginners said...

Great article, great post. Thanks for sending this in.

11:30 PM, February 09, 2010  
Anonymous miguel said...

In 2007, some went to the stock market as experts predicted that at least for another year upward trend would continue.
Attracted new investors, borrowed leaving their homes, vehicles and other assets as collateral. In April of that year the Peruvian stock market experienced its worst fall in 20 years. Everyone wanted to sell shares, there were no buyers and prices fell sharply higher. Many lost everything.

3:43 PM, March 29, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Earning money online never been this easy and transparent. You would find great tips on how to make that dream amount every month. So go ahead and click here for more details and open floodgates to your online income. All the best.

12:07 AM, August 25, 2010  
Blogger himparkh said...

one way out of such a predicament is a "helicopter drop"--effectively dropping money from helicopters to consumers and businesses below in order to thwart deflation, stimulate spending and prevent economic stagnation.
more on covered call screener

3:16 AM, December 22, 2010  
Anonymous share tips said...

Thanks so much for this! I haven't been this moved by a blog for a long time! You’ve got it, whatever that means in blogging. Anyway, You are definitely someone that has something to say that people need to hear. Keep up the good work. Keep on inspiring the people!
Share Tips

7:00 AM, May 18, 2011  
Anonymous ayala land premier said...

Philippines Web Design

Song Lyrics

1:12 AM, October 26, 2011  
Anonymous Penny stocks said...

I have a web site where I give advise on penny stocks and stocks under five dollars. I have many many years of experience with these type of stocks. If their is anyone that is interested in these type of stocks you can check out my web site by just clicking Penny stock newsletter. I would like to take a moment to talk about low price stocks not classic penny stocks or stocks under one dollar the term most people most often think of when the word penny stock is used. Their are companies of really decent quality trading under five dollars’ but for every one company trading under five dollars that is of decent quality their are maybe ten of poor quality. So the really big difference between those investors that are tremendously successfull when it comes to investing in low price stocks and those investors that lose enormous amounts of money investing in stocks under five dollars’ is having a great deal of knowledge and experience when it comes to low price stocks’ or having a total lack of knowledge and experience when it comes to low price stocks. Finding quality stocks under five dollars requires a lot more research than finding a decent stock above ten dollars.

9:23 PM, October 29, 2011  
Anonymous gold american eagles said...

gold american eagles

12:15 PM, December 13, 2011  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nice idea.. thanks for sharing.

2:26 AM, May 20, 2012  
Anonymous sterling silver earring said...

very nice post

2:11 AM, December 04, 2012  
Anonymous Houseboat Hire said...

Great info.I like all your post.I will keep visiting this blog very often.It is good to see you verbalize from the heart and your clarity on this important subject can be easily observed..

1:28 AM, December 17, 2012  
Anonymous handmade wedding invitations said...

A very well-written post. I read and liked the post and have also bookmarked you. All the best for future endeavors.

4:52 AM, December 28, 2012  
Anonymous spray olive oil said...

Very nice blog on this website. It is really difficult to get this kind of with useful information. I am relieved I came upon this site.I will eagerly look forward to your upcoming updates. Thanks for sharing it here.

11:45 PM, December 30, 2012  
Anonymous Motorhome diy said...

Yes a brilliant article Im pleased to have found it..Super Duper posting, whenever I come across a blog that really has some excellent unique content I always want to say thankyou, there are so many blogs nowadays that are full of copied content.

3:31 AM, January 18, 2013  
Blogger Webmaster said...

Lloyd your investment blog is great, what are you suggestion about etf trend system apps and software. What do you believe about ETF trading system and your experience with any.

11:04 PM, May 28, 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hyderabad-based Dr Reddy's Laboratories surpassed analysts' expectations with consolidated net profit growing 69.4 percent year-on-year to Rs 690.3 crore in three-month period ended September 2013.


2:50 AM, October 31, 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is very nice post and have great information. I also have a info about a new project Nirmal Olympia, Mulund West, Mumbai. Find More information of this Project like reviews, Specifications, price list, Floor Plans on Olympia Mulund West

4:34 AM, April 23, 2014  
Blogger Wania Sheikh said...

Thanks for sharing this blog. This is really amazing information. Do write more about Mutual Funds in Pakistan .

3:06 AM, February 25, 2019  

Post a Comment

<< Home