Monday, March 14, 2005

Suburban Condos: A Good Opportunity . . . for Somebody Else

In my town (Bellevue, WA) a new multi-family listing just hit the market: 12 one-bedroom condo units being sold as a package for $1.032 million. These units are sprinkled throughout a 240-unit condominium complex built in 1978 that happens to be located right across the street from the Microsoft campus. The units are 680 sq. ft. each, which is the perfect size for an aspiring, young software engineer who works long hours and must live close to the office. At $86,000 per unit, or $126 per rentable sq. ft., these suburban condos look extremely cheap when compared to $200 per sq. ft. for other condos of similar age and $400 per sq. ft. for new downtown condos.

I have seen suburban condos in this and surrounding complexes near the Microsoft campus come on the market over the past few years. Beyond their cheapness compared to downtown condos, what surprises me is how suburban condos have been lagging the detached house market, with the condos appreciating just 5% per year compared to 10% for detached houses:

Property: Price in 2001 vs. Price Today

Surburban Condo: $71,000 vs. $86,000
Typical Detached House: $300,000 vs. $440,000
Prce Ratio: 1-to-4.2 vs. 1-to-5.1

Because I believe it inevitable that the surburban condo market will "catch up" (and most likely sooner rather than later) with the rest of the residential real estate market, I think the upside over the next few years is very good for an investment in the 12 units now on the market. These particular suburban condos are the least expensive for-sale units in the local housing market and are priced far below replacement cost. The downside is that rising interest rates could lead to a softening of the entire residential market, possibly impacting first-time condo buyers the most (but this could also drive first-time homebuyers back into rentals, pushing rents up and producing better cash flow for condo owners who rent their units out). Balancing limited supply against potentially softening demand, I think that upward price pressure will win out, producing healthy returns for the investor who ends up buying the condo package.

Despite this excellent opportunity to invest in the condos, two factors prevent me from moving ahead to buy the package:

1. Very low cash flow: Priced at a 4% advertised cap rate (or 3% after taking reserves for capital expenditures and running numbers more realistically), the condos will conservatively support only about 50% loan-to-value and provide very little cash flow;

2. Better alternative investment opportunity: On a leveraged basis with 10% price appreciation, a 20% ROI can result from the condo investment. As attractive as this might be, I believe that better returns are available from wise investment choices in the stock market. I provide an example below.

Since an investor would need to operate the condos as rentals while waiting for them to appreciate in value, let's compare the condo investment to one of the large apartment REITs, Apartment Investment and Management Co. (Aimco, ticker: AIV):

Investment: Suburban Condos vs. REIT (Aimco)

Price: $1.032 mil. (list price) vs. $10.4 bil. (enterprise value)
Revenue: $84,000 (rent) vs. $1.47 bil. (total income)
Price-to-Revenue Ratio: 12.3 (GRM) vs. 7.1 (EV/total income)

Net Operating Income: $42,000 (pro forma) vs. $700 mil. (2004)
Cap Rate: 4.1% vs. 6.7%

Loans: $671,000 (assume 65% LTV) vs. $6.8 bil. (loans + pref.)
Interest Expense: $40,000 (6.0%) vs. $385 mil. (5.7%)

Net Income: $2,000 vs. $315 mil.
Equity: $361,000 vs. $3.6 bil. (market capitalization)
Current ROE (before deprec.): 0.5% vs. 8.7%

Est. 5-yr. Income Growth: 3% to 5% (rent inflation) vs. 4.7% (consensus)

As the numbers indicate, the REIT opportunity wins out as an income property investment:

* Better top-line income multiplier (GRM)
* Better bottom-line earnings ratio (cap rate)
* Better cash flow (current return)
* Similar earnings growth prospects

Where the condo investment should excel is in higher asset price appreciation. Let's assume that the condos appreciate at 10% per year over the next 5 years, and that the apartments in Aimco's portfolio see just half of this appreciation. We can then compare pro forma investment performance:

Annual NOI Increase: 4% for both condos and REIT
5-Yr. Asset Price Appreciation: 10% (condos) vs. 5% (REIT)
Round-Trip Expenses: 8% of exit price (condos) vs. nil (REIT)
Leverage: 65% LTV for both condos and REIT

Equity Investment ROI: 20% (condos) vs. 21% (REIT)

The higher asset price appreciation for the condo investment is largely offset by the better underlying cash flow the REIT investment offers. When the expenses (broker's commissions and transfer tax) involved in selling the condos are factored in, the pro forma ROI for the REIT investment ends up slightly ahead, 20% vs. 21%.

When I also consider the better liquidity that the REIT investment offers and the substantial amount of management time that I would have to expend buying, operating and later selling all of the condos (I speak from experience, having owned and managed apartment buildings over the years), I decide against pursuing the condo package. I need to see significantly higher expected returns from direct ownership of real property than are avaliable in the stock market before I become a landlord again.

13 Comments:

Blogger Sports Junky said...

Your post is great and let me say

A favorite pastime of mine is Sports Betting to make a few extra bucks.
My only problems is that I was never good at picking teams or games.
Recently I found a site that is like Sports Betting but I dont lose my money if my pick is bad.

Its a sports stock market, kinda like NASDAQ. which makes a big difference because if I buy shares in a team. I keep the stock whether they win or lose, but as a bonus I get paid divdends if they win.
So I can make money with dividends and also from selling high and buying low.

I buy shares in NFL, NASCAR, NCAAB, MLB, Golf, Tennis ect....
They just released Some Great IPOS's this week!

Heres a link http://allsportsmarket.com
you can log in and check it out for free..


Keep up the good work on your blog!
-Erik

12:19 PM, October 14, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is a good post. I have a site about wisconsin real estate please look at it if you can.

12:59 AM, October 25, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice post. commerce bank

1:01 AM, October 27, 2005  
Blogger Katherine said...

Great investment opportunity in Costa Rica: jaco beach real estate, map jaco beach, hotel in jaco beach costa rica. Visit us for more info at: http://www.jaco-bay.com/

6:39 PM, September 18, 2007  
Blogger costa rica said...

These articles are fantastic; the information you show us is interesting for everybody and is really good written. It’s just great!! Do you want to know something more? Read it...: Great investment opportunity in Costa Rica: jaco beach real estate, map jaco beach, hotel in jaco beach costa rica. Visit us for more info at: http://www.jaco-bay.com/

11:30 AM, September 27, 2007  
Blogger Omar Cruz said...

I like this blog is fantastic, is really good written. Congratulation. Do you want to see something more? Read it...:Great investment opportunity in Costa Rica: beach real estate, condo, condos for sale. Visit us for more info at: http://www.costa-ricarealestate.com

5:20 PM, February 13, 2008  
Blogger atayala said...

Great investment opportunity to all of us.

Deirdre G

condo manila

11:42 PM, May 23, 2010  
Anonymous condo in Philippines said...

Oh' thanks for sharing this update. I enjoyed reading it. Looking forward for your next post.

-pia-

7:55 PM, June 13, 2011  
Anonymous Web Design said...

Thanks for the post. I liked it. Keep going I follow you.

10:50 PM, September 21, 2011  
Anonymous Penny Stock Newsletter said...

I would like to comment about the real estate business whether its buying and selling homes fixing them up what have you. I do not have anything against real estate investing. But lets be clear this is a business just like if I own a used car lot a health food store a convenient store any variety of businesses. Each type of business has its own little little quirks of sorts real estate is no different. To many folks look upon real estate as an investment and that is why they fail to succeed in the real estate business' when in fact it is clearly a business thats how one should look upon real estate. A good example of this is commercial real estate. When ever I drive around I see many almost empty or completely empty stripe shopping stripes. I don't mean big box stores that are empty. I talking about a small commercial buildings that might house ten or at most fifthteen small mom and pop businesses along a major thoroughfare. I have seen dozens and dozens of partially or completly vacant stripe shopping stripes and I don't live in detroit. I live in the suburbs of chicago and this is not something recent. I have seen this five ten fifthteen years ago so what does that tell you about investing in commercial real estate. Their must be many problems with these type of properties.

10:09 AM, February 01, 2012  
Blogger Olya Olegovna said...

chalet a louer
Thank you for sharing this article. I love it. Keep on writing this type of great stuff.

12:20 AM, August 31, 2012  
Anonymous Poker Bonus said...

Many thanks for this excelent blog post.
--------------
Holdem Poker
Internet Poker
Antonius became even more famous when in 2009 he became the first poker player to accept the "durrrr Challenge". The online high-stakes duel Tom Dwan put up $ 1.5 million, and Patrick Antonius $ 500,000. Under the agreement, the player who, after 50,000 hands heads-up will have a better score wins Puke $ 2,000,000. At the moment, both players played only 39,436 hands of the planned number of 50,000 - so the challenge remains unresolved, although Durrrr leads at the moment, being in the black $ 2,059,719.5.
Start Bonus
So let's get back to the biography, Patrik Anto-Nius. Born on 13 December 1980 in Helsinki. Even as a child interested in sports, dividing his time between workouts football, hockey and tennis bonus for poker. When he was 13 he decided to focus on the tennis dreaming of a career tennis. Even then became interested in poker, often spending long hours on games with his friends. Unfortunately tennis career plans thwarted Antonius back problems which resulted in more time spent at the poker table.
Laptop Sale
TV Promo
Free Online Poker playing now, Texas holdem no limit tours, no deposit free casino and poker omaha bonus
Candida Cure

12:03 AM, June 30, 2013  
Anonymous Free Poker said...

Your blog is very interesting to me.
--------------
Poker at Night
free poker
Patrik Antonius is one of the most recognizable poker players in the world. His first major tournament success is the final table in 2005 at the European Poker Tour (EPT) in Barcelona, ??where he eventually finished third place. Later that same year was the first WPT event in Baden bei Wien (win € 343,366). A very successful 2005 years ended being careful to collection 2 place at the WPT Five Diamond World Poker Classic. Overall, in 2005-2008, Patrik won the tournament Live close to $ 3 million (including 12 WSOP cashes, seven time in hand WPT, EPT victory).
No Deposit for You.
Poker
More than poker success with Patrik Antonius is known cash game games at the highest bonus available rate (high stakes). For this reason, it has often been a guest programs such as High Stakes Poker and Poker Afer Dark. Following his poker skirmish in the programs viewers repeatedly witnessed unconventional plays, particularly interesting bluffs. It seems that a successful bluff come to him extremely easy, even for very large pools.
Free Bonus
Online Poker

12:03 AM, June 30, 2013  

Post a Comment

<< Home